Steve Caruso Beats Me to the Punch and More

Check out Steve’s new analysis of the texts of the Jordan Codices. I’ve been working on the same patterns, but Steve was quicker on the draw (this isn’t over, Steve). The use of a number of stamps has been suggested in the past based on the frequent repetition of the menorah, the two different styles of trees, etc. See also the two different versions of the “Christ” face:

You can see the mold was manipulated somewhat after the stamp impression was made and before the casting was done. The images are not identical, but come from the same stamp. I cannot agree that this impression comes from a Mona Lisa image, though. This would require the forger created a three dimensional copy of the Mona Lisa image for the stamp. It would have been much easier to us an existing stamp image, and the helios coins are obviously the closest match (although I have not found an exact match). In the copper codex that was falsified by Peter Thonemann the stamps were just fake ancient coins. Earlier Robert Deutsch felt he identified the exact fake for the chariot scene:

But on the codex the head of the second horse from the right is longer and actually has a more vertical orientation compared to the other horse heads to its left and right. The horses’ knees are also not in line on the codex:

This is the fake used in the impression. The difference is pretty minute, but it is there:

The fake coin used to produce the profile of Alexander the Great with the lion’s skin has also been identified. Here’s an overlay of the copper codex image and the fake coin:

For those who want to go digging for a source, a page shared in Prof. Davies’ editorial reproduces a photo given him by David Elkington of a codex with the impression of a clearly modern coin/plaque of some kind. I know I have seen this face before before, but I cannot place it at the moment (it is presumably supposed to be Jesus). If anyone reading recognizes the man in the codex, please let us know:

Long ago I pointed to the very clear iconographic relationships shared by the copper codices and the lead codices. The exact tree image found on the copper codex is found on about a dozen different lead codices being promoted as genuine by Elkington, as well as the same lettering and ornamentation. More evidence for this has come forward, such as the Herodian symbol found on the codex Elkington himself is flaunting as a forgery. As Steve very perceptively notes in his new post, we have yet to see a photo of a codex that does not bear clear indications of forgery. If Elkington has genuine codices, he’s hiding them. Note also Steve’s comment about the hammering out of the images on the one codex from the Facebook page. This is especially important because Elkington claims on that page that there is no iconography on that side of the plate because it is the “back page.” This is rather transparent deception on the part of Mr. Elkington. There is more deception in his attribution of several texts on that page to “experts,” “third party journalists,” and “professors,” when the texts are very clearly written by Elkington himself (note phrases he uses repeatedly in his own writing, like “at the highest level,” “of ancient provenance,” and “meaning and/or interpretation”). He’s trying to build up some authority around his fraud, but it’s painfully transparent that he alone is responsible for all of it.

Finally, just today Elkington put a link on the Facebook page to a blog called Heavenly Ascents, by a friend of mine named David Larsen (PhD candidate at St. Andrews). I don’t think Elkington has read all David’s posts on the codices (he cites me and Peter Thonemann, for instance), but for now he recommends it as fair and balanced. That’s a step forward from deleting and barring all posters who challenge Elkington’s claims.

About these ads

7 responses to “Steve Caruso Beats Me to the Punch and More

  • epatt72

    What is the size of the image of the face? The sharp edges around the ‘eyelids’ and the circle around the outside suggest to me that this came from a large medal or plaque as opposed to a coin. My first impression was that it looks like the images you see on Confederate medals commemorating the American Civil War. It is also vaguely reminiscent of the self-portrait of Da Vinci as reproduced on copper medals, but flipped horizontally. It has to be from the Medieval period forward. (Did 33 year old Jewish men of the first century have furrowing between the eyes and look twice their age?) I’ll keep looking.

    • Daniel O. McClellan

      I don’t know the size, but most of these codices are pretty small. I was thinking Civil War era as well. It seems to me there is a standing collar visible under the man’s left jaw line. He’s also got a mustache and a goatee.

      • epatt72

        Yes, that is what attracts me to the Civil War era – the goatee, military collar and flared hair. Most artistic representations of Jesus, as you know, have a full beard with a “part” down the middle. By increasing contrast and utilizing some filters in Photoshop it appears there might be additional elements to this image. For example, in the top right as you view the picture above the eye there is what appears to be the body of a soldier wearing a helmet lunging forward with a bayonet. It might be anomalistic due to the angle of the photo and the lighting, but until it is positively identified I am not discounting any possibilities that might aid in the search.

  • Jordan Lead Codices: Case Closed as “Genuine” Forgeries? « The Musings of Thomas Verenna

    [...] be the final nail in the coffin on these codices. UPDATE (8/30/11; 1:30PM EST) Steve Caruso and Dan McClellan have posted up some great material today, absolutely fascinating, and it must be shared. First, [...]

  • deutschrRobert Deutsch

    I wonder, your time has no value ?

  • PaleoBabble » Update on the Lead Codices Fakery

    [...] he focuses on analysis. For insights into the fabrication of the artistic work on the codices, this analysis is a must read. On the lettering, this demonstration of forgery is short but important. For those [...]

  • September 2011 Biblical Studies Carnival Episode III: The Final Frontier as the Carnival Strikes Back « Exploring Our Matrix

    [...] dishonesty related to the Jordanian lead books, offered photos of the codices, and said that Steve beat and punched him…or something like that. One site about them has a definite sci-fi feel to it. It is also [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 246 other followers

%d bloggers like this: