Yhwh, God of Edom

Goddess from Horvat Qitmit

I’m working on a portion of my thesis that discusses the earliest history of the Israelite deity Yhwh, and I think some of the material merits sharing. A lot of people may not be aware of the evidence that exists that Yhwh was originally a deity from the southwestern territory of Edom, on the west of the Arabah, a large valley running south from the Dead Sea down to the gulf of Aqabah. The evidence begins in the Hebrew Bible with a small number of early biblical texts that suggest Yhwh originated in that area:

Deut 33:2: Yhwh came from Sinai, and rose up unto us from Seir; he shined forth from mount Paran.

Judg 5:4–5: Yhwh, when you went out of Seir, when you marched forth from the field of Edom, the earth trembled, and the heavens dropped; yea, the clouds dropped water. The mountains quaked before the presence of Yhwh, the one of Sinai; from before Yhwh, the God of Israel.

Hab 3:3: God came from Teman, and the Holy One from mount Paran.

Seir is understood to have been located on the east side of the Arabah, where the Edomites were originally settled. They would later expand into the west, displacing the Horites. Mount Paran is likely to be located near the wilderness of Paran, located west of the Arabah. No one knows the exact location of Mount Sinai, but guesses range from the south of the Sinai peninsula up and over the gulf of Aqabah into the east, Midianite territory. Given Moses stumbles upon the mountain while tending to his Midianite father-in-law’s sheep, it’s probably not too far from the eastern side of the Arabah. Teman is on the western edge of the Arabah.

Now, the exodus tradition has Yhwh first reveal himself in this territory to a man who just married into a Midianite priest’s family. That priest, Jethro/Reuel, calls upon Yhwh’s name and even presides over sacrifices offered to him (Exod 18:10–12). Could the Midianites and Edomites have worshipped Yhwh? The Bible warns the Israelites not to hate the Edomites, since “they are your brothers,” and there is no mention of an Edomite deity anywhere in the Hebrew Bible (nor can I find a reference to a uniquely Midianite deity). This stands in contrast to the polemic leveled against the patron deities of the other nations surrounding Israel, including to the south. It also stands in contrast to the approbation of violence perpetrated against the Edomites and Midianites elsewhere in the Bible. Phineas, for example, was championed for slaughtering an Israelite who brought a Midianite woman into the camp (Num 25:1–9), but Moses, who commanded the Israelites not mix with Midianites, was married to the daughter of a Midianite priest! This suggests the larger exodus tradition dates to a much later period than the tradition associated with Moses’ early family life, when the Midianites and Edomites were enemy peoples.

We also have non-biblical references to Yhwh’s location in Edomite territory. At Kuntillet ‘Ajrud, a way station west of the Arabah, an inscription was discovered that calls the Israelite deity “Yhwh of Teman.” Some Egyptian sources also link Yhwh with the territory. Two texts, one from the fourteenth century BCE and another from the thirteenth century BCE, mention “the land of the Shasu, namely Yhw’.” This casts the Tetragrammaton as a toponym associated with the Shasu, who were nomads (the meaning of “Shasu”) located in the region of Edom, according to other Egyptian texts. Scholars generally agree that the Shasu contributed stock, if not the primary line, to the subsequent Israelite ethnos. That ethnos is first attested at the end of the thirteenth century BCE in a victory stela erected by the Egyptian Merneptah. That stela describes “Israel” as a people, and likely locates them in the central hill country of northern Israel.

This may all help explain why no other culture of Canaan worshipped Yhwh. Baal, El, and Asherah seem to be deities acknowledged and revered by multiple ethnicities in Canaan, but Yhwh is Israel’s alone. They were indigenous, he was imported. The conflict that is constantly highlighted in the Bible between Yhwh and Baal is intriguing in light of the complete absence of any such conflict between Yhwh and the Canaanite patriarchal deity El. Judg 5:4–5 gives us clues. Yhwh’s power is described with imagery associated with the storm deity motif. The same can be said of numerous other texts. Psalm 29, for instance, refers repeatedly to thunder and lightning as expressions of Yhwh’s glory. Baal was also a storm deity, and while deities performing the same function within the pantheon could be tolerated across national borders (see chapter 1 here), in the same region, there would be room enough only for one. Baal and Yhwh were thus in constant competition for devotees of the local storm deity. Yhwh did not bring imagery associated with the patriarchal deity to Canaan, but rather he appropriated that imagery, along with the station, from the local Canaanite patriarchal deity. There was no need to combat his influence.

Thus, an Edomite deity from around the Arabah was brought north to the central highlands around the end of the thirteenth century. At some point a federation or coalition of tribes dedicated to this deity coalesced, perhaps as described in the Song of Deborah in Judges 5, and developed into a state.

Here are some scholarly articles for further reading, if you’re interested in the topic:

N. Amzallag, “Yahweh, the Canaanite God of Metallurgy?JSOT 33.4 (2009): 387-404.

J. Blenkinsopp, “The Midianite-Kenite Hypothesis Revisited and the Origins of Judah,” JSOT 33.2 (2008): 131-53.

J. Kelley, “Toward a new synthesis of the god of Edom and Yahweh,” Antiguo Oriente: Cuadernos del Centro de Estudios de Historia del Antiguo Oriente 7 (2009).

T. Schneider, “The First Documented Occurrence of the God Yahweh? (Book of the Dead Princeton ‘Roll 5′),” JANER 7.2 (2007): 113-20.

N. Shupak, “The God from Teman and the Egyptian Sun God: A Reconsideration of Habakkuk 3:3-7,” JANES 28 (2001): 97-116.

About these ads

26 responses to “Yhwh, God of Edom

  • YHWH: An Imported Deity? | Ex Libris

    [...] Yhwh, God of Edom | Daniel O. McClellan [...]

  • Brian LePort

    Very interesting! Thanks for sharing. This makes me rethink the identity of Moses’ father-in-law Jethro, who is a priest in Midian without any negative disclaimers to prevent us from understanding him to be a priest in a positive way.

  • Foundations

    Yah maybe more ancient/universal rather than being from Edom/Midian (even if were so where did the Edom/Midian one come from?)

    Possible cognates of Yah/Yhwh around ancient world:
    America – Jehu (inscription)? Yaotl? Teotl? Jacy? ‘-ihah’ (Mormon)? Taiowa (sun god Hopi)? Yocahu?
    African – Yayu? Xewioso? Jakomba? Yo?
    Italy – Janus? Jove? Jas (Abraxas)?
    Greek – Iao? Ievs/Zeus/Jeoud? Iacchus? Chaos?
    ["Cyprus"?] – Ia-dan?
    Egypt – Iahu? Yah/Aah (Thoth/Sin)? (Ja-)im-hotep (Wyatt)? Mosakayahu? Heh?
    Ethiopia – Yaro/Yero?
    Egypt/Shasu – Yhw/Jhw/Yahu [hill god, M Murray]?
    Arabia/Midian – hwhy/yhwh/yhhw/whhy (Lawz inscription, Cornuke)? Yaghuth/”Jeush” (time)? Yahya (John)?
    Israel – Jas/Jach/Yah/’-iah’ /Yhwh/Yahweh/Jehovah /Yod /Eyah (“speaker”/”I Am”, El/Adonai, Arad)? Yeshua? Eve? Jave (Cain)?
    Syria/Phoenicia/Canaan – Iao? Yaw? Yam(m)? Ya (Ebla)? Yeya (lord/god)?
    Gnostic/Kosmon – ‘Eee-A-O’/Iaoth/Yaoth
    Mesopotamia – Ea/Hea/Yav/en-Ki (Lochore//Massey)? Ya (Ebla)? Zu?
    Afghan – Dezau?
    Indus/India – Yaya (Hrozny)? Dyaus?
    China – Yao (Velikovsky)? Tao? nu-Kwa? Yi (Hrozny)? Yu?
    Maori – Io/Iho/Kiho? Atua?

    Not sure if the D-/T- versions (Dyaus/Zeus/Teotl) are related or not?

    * Cronus->Zeus ~ Elohim->Yhwh?

  • jasondulle

    Some thoughts and questions.

    Does the mere fact that the name of God, YHWH, predates Israel mean that they borrowed YHWH from the Edomites?

    And what reason do we have to believe that the YHWH the Edomites followed is the same YHWH the Israelites followed? Couldn’t they have conceived of this god differently (similarly to how Jews and Christians both speak of “God,” and yet have very different understandings about the nature and character of God).

    And I’m not sure how amazed we should be that someone else other than Israel might have a god named YHWH given it’s basic meaning (“He is,” or something similar). It could even be the case that YHWH revealed himself to the ancestors of the Edomites, and while they retained His name in their worship they perverted His identity through syncretism.

    • Daniel O. McClellan

      I’m not suggesting borrowing so much as migrating. Segments of the Edomite population who worshipped YHWH seem to have migrated to the north, taking their deity with them and making up a fragment of the earliest Israelite ethnos. The local deity would have been the Canaanite patriarchal deity El. It’s unlikely this is a different YHWH because there is no other attestation of that divine name except among the Israelites, and it appears just before the Israelite ethnos appears.

    • Stephanie

      I do agree….nothing new under the sun….serving the Most High in action is worship and not just using a name and calling him your own….good example: chritians and jews.

  • Scripturefocus

    So, Danny, how do your Mormon comrades like your thoughts?

  • Ron Den Boer

    The Book of Mormon contradicts the whole concept of the Nature of the Godhead and Nature of Jesus the way Joseph Smith taught and agrees completely with the Creeds of the 4th and 5th century. 2 Nephi 26:12, Alma 11:44, Mosiah 3:5 and 5:15 etc

  • Ivan Komotios

    Could Daniel O. McClellan produce some verses in the Book of Mormon to substantiate his finding ?

    “The Prophet Joseph Smith said, “I told the brethren that the Book of Mormon was the most correct of any book on earth, and the keystone of our religion, and a man would get nearer to God by abiding by its precepts, than by any other book” (T. of P.J.S., p. 194).

    He also said, “Take away the Book of Mormon and the revelations, and where is our religion? We have none” (Ibid., p. 71). But, Smith’s successor, LDS Prophet Brigham Young, said, “There is the New Testament; you may leave out the Book of Mormon and the Book of Doctrine and Covenants, and follow the precepts of that book faithfully, and I will warrant you to arrive at salvation” (J. of D., Vol. I, p. 244). This is another example of LDS prophetic inconsistency.

    LDS Apostle Orson Pratt wrote a series of questions and answers in which he said, “Q. What will be the consequences if they (the United States) do not embrace the Book of Mormon as a divine revelation? A. They will be destroyed from the land and sent down to hell, like all other generations who have rejected a divine message” (The Seer, p. 215). The United States still has not embraced the B. of M. after more than 150 years, but they have not been destroyed either!

    Pratt also said, “Before this [the B. of M.] was offered to the world, the Lord confirmed it by opening the heavens in broad daylight, and sending down an holy angel, who descended in the presence of four individuals, three besides Mr. Smith, and the angel took the plates, and turned them over leaf after leaf, while, at the same time, the voice of the Lord out of the heavens told them it had been translated correctly, commanding them to send forth their testimony to all nations, Kingdoms, tongues, and people” (J. of D., Vol. II, p. 293).

    • Daniel O. McClellan

      My blog isn’t about Mormonism, so if you’ve got a contribution to make to the post, make it, but if you’re just here to spew belligerent sectarian nonsense, I’m not going to let you continue to post.

  • NRA Jeff

    Like others, I find your research fascinating. It provides a backdrop to the OT story that is only vaguely mentioned in the OT, if at all. Thanks for sharing this. — NRA Jeff

    • Ron Den Boer

      Joseph Smith: Many men say there is one God; the Father, the son and the Holy Ghost are only one God! I say this is a strange God anyhow—three in one, and one in three! It is a curious organization. . . . All are to be crammed into one God, according to sectarianism. It would make the biggest God in all the world. He would be a wonderfully big God—he would be a giant or a monster.“
      (History of the Church * Volume 6 Page 476 * 1844

      “God himself was once as we are now, and is an exalted Man, and sits enthroned in yonder heavens. That is the great secret… …I am going to tell you how God came to be God. We have imagined and supposed that God was God from all eternity. I will refute that idea, and take away the veil, so that you may see. … It is the first principle of the Gospel to know for a certainty the character of God and to know…that he was once a man like us…. Here, then, is eternal life – to know the only wise and true God; and you have got to learn how to be Gods yourselves, and to be kings and priests to God, the same as all Gods have done before you… (“King Follett Discourse,” Journal of Discourses 6:3-4, also in Teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith, 345-346, and History of the Church, vol. 6, 305-307,)”

      As man is, God once was; as God is, man may become.
      Author: Lorenzo Snow
      Source: Gospel Through The Ages
      Chapter: 43
      Page: 105

      Joseph Smith’s statement here is very strange when he taught this until about 1835

      2 Nephi 31:
      21 And now, behold, my beloved brethren, this is the way; and there is none other way nor name given under heaven whereby man can be saved in the kingdom of God. And now, behold, this is the doctrine of Christ, and the only and true doctrine of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost, which is one God, without end. Amen.

      Alma 11:
      44 Now, this restoration shall come to all, both old and young, both bond and free, both male and female, both the wicked and the righteous; and even there shall not so much as a hair of their heads be lost; but everything shall be restored to its perfect frame, as it is now, or in the body, and shall be brought and be arraigned before the bar of Christ the Son, and God the Father, and the Holy Spirit, which is one Eternal God, to be judged according to their works, whether they be good or whether they be evil.

      Mormon 7:
      7 And he hath brought to pass the redemption of the world, whereby he that is found guiltless before him at the judgment day hath it given unto him to dwell in the presence of God in his kingdom, to sing ceaseless praises with the choirs above, unto the Father, and unto the Son, and unto the Holy Ghost, which are one God, in a state of happiness which hath no end.

      The Testimony of Three Witnesses
      And the honor be to the Father, and to the Son, and to the Holy Ghost, which is one God. Amen.
      Oliver Cowdery
      David Whitmer
      Martin Harris

      Doctrine and Covenants 20 :
      28 Which Father, Son, and Holy Ghost are one God, infinite and eternal, without end. Amen.

      2 Nephi 26:12 And as I spake concerning the convincing of the Jews, that Jesus is the very Christ, it must needs be that the Gentiles be convinced also that Jesus is the Christ, the Eternal God;

      Moroni 7:22 For behold, God knowing all things, being from everlasting to everlasting , behold, he sent angels to minister unto the children of men, to make manifest concerning the coming of Christ; and in Christ there should come every good thing.

      Moroni 8:18 For I know that God is not a partial God, neither a changeable being; but he is unchangeable from all eternity to all eternity.

      Mormon 9:9 For do we not read that God is the same yesterday, today, and forever , and in him there is no variableness neither shadow of changing?

      Hebrews 12: 8 Jesus Christ the same yesterday, and to day, and for ever.

      Mosiah 3:5 For behold, the time cometh, and is not far distant, that with power, the Lord Omnipotent who reigneth, who was, and is from all eternity to all eternity, shall come down from heaven among the children of men, and shall dwell in a tabernacle of clay, and shall go forth amongst men, working mighty miracles, such as healing the sick, raising the dead, causing the lame to walk, the blind to receive their sight, and the deaf to hear, and curing all manner of diseases.

  • Charles

    I find your research fascinating as I took have found that the Edomites brought Yahweh with them to Israel. From my notes which I lost I remember that Yahu was a deity of Africa and the Arab deserts. That Yahweh is described as a storm God is perfectly in line with other religions depictions of the Sumerian Enki who was also a Storm God.

    Firstly thank you very much for taking the time to research this topic. I too have found in my personal research that the Edomites who were locals of Mount Seir/Sin/Sinai brought their desert deity that is also found in Arabia and Africa into the Kingdom of Israel.

    That Yahweh is described as a storm god just as Sumerian Enki, Egyptian Osiris, Canaanite Baal, Greek Zeus, Nordic Odin, Roman Jupiter, Carthaginian Baal-Hammon, and Phoenician Melqart is telling in the extreme.

    An/Anu,and El never being described as storm gods but instead as sky gods.

    It stands to reason that since Ram known as Abram and Abraham was from Sumeria that the Hebrew pantheon is Sumerian and that El of the Hebrews is the same as Anu of the Sumerians. This would indicate that after falling from grace the Israelite kingdom began worshiping Enki in place of El under the name Yahweh.

    In the Sumerian religion Enki is God of the Earth. In the Hebrew Bible Lucifer is God of this World. If the Hebrew religion comes from Sumeria then Lucifer is Enki and Satan is his son the Sumerian god Marduk.

    In the Sumerian religion after Anu and Enlil God the Father and God the Son decided that humanity should be eliminated for their transgressions via a global flood Enki saves Ziusudra by instructing him to build a massive cube structure akin to Noah’s Ark.

    In the Hebrew religion after El and Christ God the Father and God the Son decided that humanity should be eliminated for their transgressions via a global flood they had mercy on the human race and selected Noah because of his genetic perfection to survive and to do so they instructed him in the creation of the Ark.

    El and Christ / Anu and Enlil as well as Lucifer / Enki are both said through these two religions to have saved humanity from total destruction.

    On the nature of good and evil. Countless children throughout the ages have been murdered as blood sacrifices to Enki, Ninhursag and Marduk by various names. Whereas El and Christ only demanded Ram sacrifice his son Isaac to them as a test of his faith. Upon completion of the test no sacrifice was required.

    The false gods require the blood sacrifice of innocent life. The true gods require faith alone.

    I wish I had been able to retain the compiled notes on this topic, I would have been very happy to provide them to aid in your understanding.

    May I suggest you look into the concept of Zeus as a deity who was worshiped by the Egyptians as the Ba of the Lord of Djedet. Their legend goes Zeus did not want to appear to Heracles as himself and so he appeared with the head of a ram. This legend of Egyptian Mendes ties the religion of Egypt directly to the religion of Greece.

    Both of these cultures may have inherited their religions through the travels of the people of Edom. Edom while may have colonized Philistine, Phoenica, Minoa, Crete, Cyrus, Carthage, Greece, Rome, etc.

    The Edomites themselves being indoctrinated in the Babylonian religion again during their captivity in Sumerian Babylon as slaves taken from the Kingdom of Judah.

    Good luck in your research and I suggest you ignore all these people trying to distract you from this quest for knowledge of the true history of this faith.

  • Charles

    Firstly thank you very much for taking the time to research this topic. I too have found in my personal research that the Edomites who were locals of Mount Seir/Sin/Sinai brought their desert deity that is also found in Arabia and Africa into the Kingdom of Israel.

    That Yahweh is described as a storm god just as Sumerian Enki, Egyptian Osiris, Canaanite Baal, Greek Zeus, Nordic Odin, Roman Jupiter, Carthaginian Baal-Hammon, and Phoenician Melqart is telling in the extreme.

    An/Anu,and El never being described as storm gods but instead as sky gods.

    It stands to reason that since Ram known as Abram and Abraham was from Sumeria that the Hebrew pantheon is Sumerian and that El of the Hebrews is the same as Anu of the Sumerians. This would indicate that after falling from grace the Israelite kingdom began worshiping Enki in place of El under the name Yahweh.

    In the Sumerian religion Enki is God of the Earth. In the Hebrew Bible Lucifer is God of this World. If the Hebrew religion comes from Sumeria then Lucifer is Enki and Satan is his son the Sumerian god Marduk.

    In the Sumerian religion after Anu and Enlil God the Father and God the Son decided that humanity should be eliminated for their transgressions via a global flood Enki saves Ziusudra by instructing him to build a massive cube structure akin to Noah’s Ark.

    In the Hebrew religion after El and Christ God the Father and God the Son decided that humanity should be eliminated for their transgressions via a global flood they had mercy on the human race and selected Noah because of his genetic perfection to survive and to do so they instructed him in the creation of the Ark.

    El and Christ / Anu and Enlil as well as Lucifer / Enki are both said through these two religions to have saved humanity from total destruction.

    On the nature of good and evil. Countless children throughout the ages have been murdered as blood sacrifices to Enki, Ninhursag and Marduk by various names. Whereas El and Christ only demanded Ram sacrifice his son Isaac to them as a test of his faith. Upon completion of the test no sacrifice was required.

    The false gods require the blood sacrifice of innocent life. The true gods require faith alone.

    I wish I had been able to retain the compiled notes on this topic, I would have been very happy to provide them to aid in your understanding.

    May I suggest you look into the concept of Zeus as a deity who was worshiped by the Egyptians as the Ba of the Lord of Djedet. Their legend goes Zeus did not want to appear to Heracles as himself and so he appeared with the head of a ram. This legend of Egyptian Mendes ties the religion of Egypt directly to the religion of Greece.

    Both of these cultures may have inherited their religions through the travels of the people of Edom. Edom while may have colonized Philistine, Phoenica, Minoa, Crete, Cyrus, Carthage, Greece, Rome, etc.

    The Edomites themselves being indoctrinated in the Babylonian religion again during their captivity in Sumerian Babylon as slaves taken from the Kingdom of Judah.

    Good luck in your research and I suggest you ignore all these people trying to distract you from this quest for knowledge of the true history of this faith.

    Please remove my above post as there were spelling errors and blocks of text I intended to edit out of the final post. Thank you.

  • Irene Bonney

    A good article by Roger Hathaway ‘Sacred Name of God? or Blasphemy? He proposes that the Edomites hd as their deity, YHWH as a key to their magic and that when they took over Jerusalem they already had imbibed the Talmudic Pharisaical religion, Babylon. Also, and a Rev. John Cortwright states a similar belief, he says that the Septuagont of 285 Bc did not use the name for Yhwh but ‘Kurios’, ‘Lord’. Philo, Josephus, Eusebius and Aristeas never used any name for God. Unfortunately, most English translations follow the Masoretic Text of the Talmudic Jews.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 256 other followers

%d bloggers like this: